CALDWELL, Idaho — The Carroll College Volleyball team lived up to their name on Saturday afternoon, fighting until the bitter end in a five-set loss at the ninth-seeded College of Idaho in the opening round of the 2026 NAIA Women's Volleyball Championship.
Making their first appearance in the NAIA Tournament since 2016, the Fighting Saints (21-12) gave the CCC Regular Season Champion and ninth-seeded Yotes all they could handle in a five-set epic.
Things got off to a shaky start for the Saints in their first tournament match in over a decade. Entering the championship with a .192 attack percentage as a team, Carroll struggled in the opening frame. The Saints hit a match-worst .086, while the hosting Yotes hit .353 to run away with a win. C of I ended the set with a 10-2 run to close out the 25-15 victory.
A Carroll team that has proven plenty capable of playing from behind all season long responded in the second set. The Saints jumped out to a 6-2 advantage, and then made their move later in the frame with a 5-0 run, capped by a Lauren Heuiser (Helena, Mont. / SR) kill and Sofia Kimmel (Bozeman, Mont. / SO) ace. The late run gave Carroll its first real momentum of the match, and following a pair of late-frame kills by Malia Allen (Great Falls, Mont. / FR), Carroll would knot things up at 1-1 with a 25-21 set win.
People are also reading…
The third frame was one of the most tightly contested all night, with neither team leading by more than three points throughout. The teams exchanged blows point after point, eventually leading to Jansyn Carrizales (Sunnyside, Wash. / SR) serving with Carroll down 23-22. C of I managed to string together a pair of kills at the end, however, taking the set 25-22 and bringing Carroll within one set of its season's close.
Carroll trailed 14-10 in the fourth before an extended run would help extend its year. A 9-2 run, spurred by four kills from Honorable Mention All-Conference selection Kaylen Hay (Pocatello, Idaho / R-SO), would vault the Saints into the driver's seat. However, the frame would not end without drama. Serving set point at 24-21, Carroll watched the Yotes punch back with three straight kills to tie things up at 24-24. The Saints would not be denied, though, as Hay powered home another kill, while Birdie Heuiser (Helena, Mont. / SO) put the set to rest with a kill of her own to force a deciding fifth frame.
The Saints did everything they could to claw their way to the NAIA's final site in Sioux City, Iowa, next month, but the Yotes were too powerful in the fifth. C of I closed out the match with a 15-10 set win, hitting a match-best .450 attack and using several timely blocks to keep Carroll at bay.
Hay led all Saints on the evening with 16 kills, one off the match-high by C of I's Alexa Wheeler. Lauren Heuiser tallied 15 kills in the final match of her storied career, while Birdie Heuiser added 13. Both sisters finished the night with a team-best two blocks on the defensive end as well.
Lauren Fox (Bozeman, Mont. / SO) led Carroll with 27 assists, just one more than Jansyn Carrizales' 26 in her final match. The pair both posted double-doubles, with Fox adding 10 digs and Carrizales 12. Norah Allen (Great Falls, Mont. / SR) led the Saints with 14 digs on the night.
The Saints were one of three Frontier Conference teams to appear in the NAIA tournament, with all three dropping their opening round contests (Bellevue: L 3-2 to OUAZ | Montana Tech: L 3-1 to SOU).

