Arlee man pleads not guilty to new homicide charge

Arlee man pleads not guilty to new homicide charge

  • 0
Johnathan Bertsch arraignment 01

Johnathan Bertsch appears for an arraignment at the Missoula County Courthouse on a new deliberate homicide charge in the back-to-back shootings last March. The new homicide charge was filed against him for the death of Julie Blanchard who died months after the shooting. Bertsch pleaded not guilty to the homicide charge. 

The Arlee man charged in back-to-back shootings last March pleaded not guilty on Thursday to a new homicide charge filed in light of one victim's death after the shooting.

Johnathan Albert Bertsch, 28, when he was arrested on March 15, 2019, now faces two counts of deliberate homicide for the deaths of Julie Blanchard and Shelley Hays, as well as two counts of attempted deliberate homicide to account for two people who survived the shootings.

Authorities allege he shot up a vehicle carrying three people on Expressway on March 14, killing 28-year-old Hays at the scene, and later ambushed a Montana Highway Patrol trooper searching for him shortly after midnight.

In recent court filings, prosecutors indicated the shooting may have been motivated by Blanchard's pickup propelling a large cloud of dark diesel exhaust over Bertsch's white SUV while leaving a bar west of Missoula. Search warrant documents show two "AR-15 style" rifles and a .45-caliber handgun were found in Bertsch's vehicle after his arrest.

Julie Blanchard

Julie Blanchard, 52

Julie Blanchard had been driving the pickup that was the shooter's first target, sustaining multiple gunshot wounds to her upper limbs and torso, according to the coroner who examined her months later. 

Blanchard died from complications from her gunshot wounds at a Washington hospital three months after the shootings. The Chelan County coroner deemed her death a homicide; after carefully examining her medical records, the Missoula County Attorney's Office concurred and swapped an attempted homicide charge for deliberate homicide in December.

Bertsch appeared to have lost some weight in his 10 months jailed at the Missoula County Detention Facility. He said little more than a meek "hello," to Judge Shane Vannatta as he stood next to his public defender, Reed Mandelko. It was the first public appearance Bertsch has made in court. He typically appears by video from the jail.

Johnathan Bertsch arraignment 02

Montana Highway Patrol Troopers show their support for Trooper Wade Palmer during an arraignment for Johnathan Bertsch.

Montana Highway Patrol brass and troopers silently filtered into the courtroom gallery's back row, and scooted out just as silently when the hearing was over. The troopers were there to represent Trooper Wade Palmer, one of the surviving shooting victims along with Casey Blanchard, Julie Blanchard's son. Palmer survived gunshot wounds to the head, face and neck, and is extending his rehabilitation at home after extensive treatment at University of Utah Hospital in Salt Lake City.

"We were there to represent Trooper Palmer at those hearings," MHP Sgt. Sean Finley said after the hearing. "He can't represent himself, he can't be there in person. So we, as an agency, feel that it's very important to be there for him."

Bertsch is scheduled for trial in August. 


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News