Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
editor's pick alert

More than $171K spent on seized Helena Valley horses so far

  • 0
Seized Horses

Volunteer Sam Heigh on Wednesday cares for a handful of the 60 horses seized by the Lewis and Clark County Sheriff's Office earlier this year.

The price tag for Lewis and Clark County to keep nearly 60 horses confiscated June 1 from a breeding operation has hit $171,481, Sheriff Leo Dutton said Tuesday, adding that he believes the number will exceed $250,000 by the time the issue is expected to be resolved in April.

The horses have been under the county’s care since the sheriff’s office, a U.S. Forest Service ranger and a Department of Livestock employee raided an operation in the Helena Valley run by Robert Erickson and sons Alan and Clayton Erickson.

They have pleaded not guilty to charges of felony aggravated abuse of animals and await an April 25 jury trial. If convicted, each defendant faces a possibility of two years imprisonment and fines totaling $2,500. They were released on their own recognizance. Attorneys for the Ericksons were not immediately available for comment Wednesday.

Of the 59 horses, 25 are now in foster care and 34 are under the sheriff’s care, officials said. 

Authorities originally removed 60 horses, but one of the horses, a mare, was destroyed, Dutton said, adding he was unable to provide details. He said all parties involved were contacted and a necropsy is still being done.

According to court documents, a vet scored 58 of the horses as underweight and said 19 of them had hooves that were severely overgrown. Many of the horses were reported as being infested with lice and at least five had abdominal hernias.

Of the $171,481 tally incurred so far, $90,875 is in operating costs, which includes hay and veterinary costs, and $80,605 is in salaries paid to those taking care of the horses, Dutton said.

Seized Horses

Of the horses seized earlier this year, 25 are now in foster care and 34 are under the sheriff’s care, officials said.

He said the money is coming from within the county budget and not from the sheriff’s department.

“I don’t have the money,” he said.

County Commissioner Jim McCormick said the county does not have a specific fund for animals but is allocating funds.

McCormick said there was not a budget for caring for confiscated animals. He said a special account has been set up to pay for the care of the horses.

"The cost isn’t a surprise at all," he said.

He said the county is obligated to take care of the horses because they are part of ongoing litigation.

"There is not much to say," he said.

Dutton said he knew he had to do the right thing when the horses were discovered and has had good community backing.

“But it all costs money,” he said, noting the horses have to be fed twice a day and watched over. They are also making plans for winter preparations.

“We are struggling, we have people working around the clock,” Dutton said. “We are not in the horse business and not equipped to handle this many horses.”

He said they have been loaned equipment and people have stepped forward to help. He said they have received $19,543 in donations, plus hay. 

“The community has been a blessing,” he said.

Dutton declined to say where they horses are now being kept. He said they are considered evidence and belong to the court and not to the sheriff’s department.

He said there are several horse rescue groups in the state who could help with the animals, “but the issue is, they are evidence.”

About 10 volunteers have been assisting the operation since the outset. Every day the horses are fed and their stalls are mucked out.

Seized Horses

Volunteer Mary Hunt talks to one of the horses seized by the Lewis and Clark County Sheriff's Office earlier this year.

"These horses need someone to feed them and take care of them," said Sam Heigh, a volunteer who's helped out since the start.

"It's so nice to see them doing better," Heigh added. "They've calmed down a lot since they've been here."

Dutton said a judge could find authorities did a proper investigation and find the defendants guilty, could release all the horses back to their owners or find the defendants guilty and have the cost of the care be borne by them.

Undersheriff Brent Colbert said an Incident Command System for the horses was set up since the beginning of the June seizure and he said he gets daily updates on the horses and their conditions.

On Tuesday the county commissioners were asked by sheriff's officials to delay a request to apply for a $5,000 grant to help pay medical expenses. Officials said it would be better to apply once the court issues were resolved.


To make a donation or volunteer, call 406-668-1091.

Staff photographer Thom Bridge contributed to this story. Story updated to say $19,543.00 received in donations. 

Seized Horses

The cost of taking care of the horses seized earlier this year has exceeded $171,000, the sheriff said.

Assistant editor Phil Drake can be reached at 406-231-9021.


Get local news delivered to your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

A wildfire that came amid unseasonably warm weather and was pushed by strong winds ripped through a tiny central Montana farming town overnight, burning 24 homes and four grain elevators that had stood for more than a century.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News