Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
editor's pick alert

Lawsuit claims delays by St. Peter's caused woman's death

  • 0
St. Peter’s Health (copy)

St. Peter’s Health in Helena. 

The estate of a woman who died from cancer is suing St. Peter’s Health, saying it dismissed her oncologist without a backup plan, delayed the results of a CT scan and removed the doctor before the woman could receive treatment.

Carol Aronen had a history of cancer. Aronen was treated with surgery and under the care of Dr. Thomas Weiner, who was fired by St. Peter’s Health in 2020. He has sued the hospital in a pending wrongful termination suit.

Aronen was a patient of Weiner at the time of his dismissal, her lawsuit states. Weiner had ordered a CT scan for Aronen. The hospital took over care of his patients when he was released. The suit states she received her results four months after her appointment with Weiner had been canceled. The results determined she had Stage 4 cancer.

Computerized tomography (CT) combines X-ray images taken from different angles around the body and uses a computer to produce images of a cross-section of the body.

She died July 14, 2021. She was 74 and a resident of Lewis and Clark County.

“The administration put profits over patients and took away Carol’s rights to her physicians,” the June 10 claim filed in 1st District Judicial Court in Lewis and Clark County by Great Falls attorney Daniel J. Flaherty states.

Aronen’s lawsuit states the replacement staff for Weiner were “understaffed, undertrained and without adequate preparation.”

St. Peter’s Health, in its Aug. 1 response, admits that Aronen was a patient being treated by Weiner and that he had ordered a CT scan for her, but either denies the other allegations or says it does not have “sufficient information” to respond.

The response by Helena attorneys Sara S. Berg and Daniel J. Auerbach representing the hospital also said the injuries were caused by superseding intervening causes of which the hospital had no control. They said they have not completed discovery in the case and reserve the right to amend their answer.

The estate seeks a jury trial, all compensatory damages allowed by law, punitive damages, costs and fees and any other damages the court deem appropriate.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on Thursday endorsed updated COVID-19 boosters, opening the way for a fall vaccination campaign that could blunt a winter surge if enough Americans roll up their sleeves. The new boosters targeting today's most common omicron strains should begin arriving in pharmacies and clinics within days. They're combination or "bivalent" shots that contain half the original vaccine that's been used since December 2020 and half protection against today's dominant omicron versions, BA.4 and BA.5. It's the first update to COVID-19 vaccines ever cleared by the Food and Drug Administration. Updated shots made by Pfizer and its partner BioNTech are authorized for anyone 12 and older, and rival Moderna's version is for adults. They're to be used as a booster for anyone who's already had their primary vaccination series -- using shots from any U.S.-cleared company -- and regardless of how many boosters they've already gotten. The FDA set the minimum wait time at two months. But advisers to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said it's better to wait longer. Some advise at least three months, another said someone who's not at high risk might wait as long as six months. It's still important to get vaccinated even if you've already been infected -- but timing matters here, too. The CDC has long told people to defer vaccination until they've recovered but also that people may consider waiting for three months after recovering to get a vaccination. And several CDC advisers say waiting the three months is important, both for potentially more benefit from the shot and to reduce chances of a rare side effect, heart inflammation, that sometimes affects teen boys and young men.

Assistant editor Phil Drake can be reached at 406-231-9021.


* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Assistant Editor/Reporter

Phil Drake is the assistant editor and reporter at the Independent Record.

Related to this story

St. Peter’s Health has asked for a change of venue in a lawsuit filed by its former oncologist against the health care facility, saying the Helena-area community has been exposed to gossip and innuendo, putting the possibility of a fair trial at risk.

Listen now and subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Google Podcasts | Spotify | Stitcher | RSS Feed | Omny Studio

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News