Recently the Helena Public Schools’ plan to teach an expanded sex-ed program has hit some pot holes. Unfortunately, there was widespread opposition to the plan when the details were released. Some people believe it is their duty to use the classroom to teach kids about sexual orientation rights. They want kids to have a better understanding of those who are gay in the hopes of lessening the societal stigma attached therewith.

The struggle for rights is the story of America. Instead of trying to censor the conversation, shouldn’t we amplify the discussion on the battle for a wide variety of rights? If we are to raise up a generation of critical thinkers, then we must challenge our young students to question all answers and to seek the truth for themselves. Exposing kids to controversial topics does not mean that there will be universal agreement, but encouraging them to form their own opinions is a vital part of their lifelong learning process. Limiting the conversation on rights to sexual orientation and sexual freedom is doing our youngsters a great disservice.

While we are at it, let’s include some other rights, which are under constant attack in this country for the classroom as well. Shouldn’t we augment the teaching of our U.S. Constitution by discussing the first 10 amendments known as the Bill of Rights? If the kids learn that the 2nd Amendment is not about hunting, they will grasp with great clarity how timeless the right to bear arms is.

Marcus Tullius Cicero was a Roman political writer who lived from 106-43 BC. He is credited frequently by the founding fathers for identifying the universal rules for a great and just society termed Natural Law. Natural Law simply codifies the “rules of right conduct.” Some of the tenets of natural law that might be familiar to you include unalienable rights, habeas corpus, limited government, family, the institution of marriage, and the right to bear arms among many others. You see the right to defend yourself, your family and your property is one of many checks and balances that is essential to maintaining a free and respectful society. Although hunting is a great sport, when you get down to brass tacks, the Second Amendment is not about hunting. Understanding the rights of our U.S. Constitution would be a solid foundation upon which to build a discussion of other rights.

The Helena school board was also trying to gird our kids with the knowledge to increase their chances of remaining disease free and of eliminating accidental pregnancies. They were simply trying to keep students safe. Likewise, if we equip students with basic gun safety knowledge, we can also keep them safe from the improper use of guns. Students could learn in an age-appropriate way to secure and disarm a gun if found. This knowledge would help to prevent accidents now and in the future. Additionally, few things give a well-trained vulnerable young lady a better chance against a would-be rapist than the proper use of a handgun.

Does the idea of discussing the merits of individual gun rights in the classroom seem inappropriate? Don’t worry; that is just one form of bias. Others felt the same way about the teaching of homosexual rights and sexual freedom rights. This will be a great opportunity for everyone to confront what he or she considers to be taboo topics.

A Helena school expanded sex-ed type program will again appear before us. If the curriculum is too narrow in its scope, critics will be able to successfully assert that it is indoctrination and not education.

We should seize the opportunity to discuss a greater diversity of rights and responsibilities in the classroom.

Rick Dow lives in Havre.

(3) comments


So.. by more rights, you mean gun rights? Just to be clear.

I wholeheartedly agree. School shouldn't be simply about teaching kids to add. It should be about teaching them how to find information, decipher it objectively - and this is key!, and to discuss and debate ideas. This screaming society of half-wits needs to end.

Teach them about the 14th amendment. Its intent. Its manipulation, and now its impacts. Not simply what the 14th says and allows, but what that means in the context of a society.

Teach them that life is a Balance between individual rights and social responsibilities - Not one or the other, black or white.

Teach them about ethics. Teach them logic. Teach them, not what to think, but how to think.

Teach them about the levels of consciousness.

...or maybe just how to load a gun.


Sounds to me like we don't even need parents anymore.


There is already an option available for this and it is called hunter safety. Anyone who hunts or, in my opinion, handles a gun, should attend.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.